CaseIH has joined New Holland and Monarch in introducing an electric tractor. We all knew that was coming. The only thing that surprises me is that it’s taken this long. Both the New Holland and CaseIH are more or less traditional looking and traditional functioning tractors. They’re considered “utility” tractors, horsepower ranges from about 75 – 80 HP, and both have run times of 4 hours+ depending on how hard you work them.
The Monarch on the other hand… Yeah, I just don’t know. First of all it’s built in partnership with Foxconn. After the way that company screwed over the state of Wisconsin I wouldn’t trust them to clean my cat’s litter box much less build a tractor that actually works. But the Monarch itself isn’t any kind of tractor that we’d find all that useful here in Wisconsin in the first place. It’s small, narrow, has tiny little tires and is frankly strange looking, loaded with radar and sensors and I don’t know what all else. Supposedly it can follow you around like a dog and, well, I’m sorry, I don’t want a tractor following me around without a driver. It might be useful for orchards or vegetable farms, but for the average farm around here? This thing is pretty much useless for someone who has to get 1,000 acres of corn into the ground or harvest 500 acres of beans. And considering all of the fragile electronics and software packed into the thing it is going to break. A lot. It looks like that aside from small vegetable and specialty crop growers this thing is aimed at wealthy hobby farmers.
How successful will these things be? Will farmers adopt them? Well, maybe? I can see these being useful. But ultimately it’s going to come down to value for money. Farmers operate on razor thin profit margins, and they are very, very cautious about adopting new technology until it’s proven itself to be economically viable. E-tractors have a lot going for them besides just not pumping out huge amounts of toxic exhaust. No more engine oil changes, no more engine filter changes, less maintenance necessary, less noise.
It’s going to come down to how reliable these things are. Are they going to be able to stand up to the day to day use and abuse the average tractor experiences during its lifetime?
grouchyfarmer 